
Comfortable win yesterday, back to the top of the league. "Bah," says
Paul Wilson in The Observer:
Don't believe the hype. While Manchester United may be back on top of the Premier League as a result of their fifth successive win coupled with Wigan's unlikely toppling of Chelsea, the extent to which the champions are relying on Ryan Giggs is in danger of becoming embarrassing.
For the second weekend in a row United were indebted to their veteran winger for securing the points, this time by coming on as a second-half substitute and showing his team-mates the way to goal. Before the 35-year-old's introduction United seemed to have no idea how to break down Stoke's massed defence. The visitors looked as if they could play all day without scoring – as indeed did Stoke, though that is nothing new – until Giggs arrived and quickly helped set up goals for Dimitar Berbatov and John O'Shea to make winning look easy again.
So embarrassing that the rest of the report lists all the chances we created... And Ryan Giggs cross was made possible by a great pass from Fletcher, who was on from the start, and who isn't Ryan Giggs. Sour grapes aren't very appetising...
So embarrassing was our reliance on Giggs that
The Independent's report singles out Scholes as the best player on the pitch, after first suggesting that he should have been sent off in an incident so important MOTD didn't even bother showing it...:
the afternoon's only moment of contention was referee Howard Webb's decision not to show Scholes a second red card in as many appearances, for a blatant handball from Liam Lawrence's cross, six minutes after his yellow for a second Scholesian tackle of the afternoon, on the same player. Scholes' salvation will perhaps have United's rivals remembering the penalty Webb handed them in the title-defining 5-2 win over Tottenham last April and scenting conspiracy.
But the afternoon belonged to the 34-year-old Scholes for more laudable reasons. Always allowed to operate with five yards of space in front of him by a Stoke midfield which was part overawed and part technically overwhelmed, he simply batted metronomic 20-yard passes to the flanks and watched United fly. There was a moment towards the end of the first half when Scholes lost a shin-pad, and after Darren Fletcher had handed it back he just resumed work, clutching it in his hand. It was that kind of walk in the park. "The best player on the pitch by a country mile," was how Pulis described Scholes later.
Sir Alex's view on the Scholes booking and handball:
"I didn't think it was handball but it would have been an injustice if he had been sent off because he was wrongly booked in the first place," said the United boss.
"He only made two tackles but Paul is an easy target for referees."
Whisper it in the heartland of functional football, but we are going to have to get used to Dimitar Berbatov’s quaint little ways.
When the tumult had died down, he removed his alice band and ambled away. It had been a gentle stroll in the autumnal sunshine.
If he broke sweat, it was an accident. He barely made a tackle, and contented himself with the occasional intelligent foray into space.
Yet a simple side-footed finish, which set up a significant win, excused all. Manchester United had emerged from the Britannia bear pit without a scratch. ...
They will never have a better opportunity to brand Berbatov as a conscientious objector under fire.
The Bulgarian had scored only once in eight previous games this season.
He had cause to be grateful for the diversion provided by Michael Owen’s sudden installation as a United legend. He had ducked under the radar, but murmured comparisons to Juan Sebastian Veron, another talented misfit, were threatening to grow to a crescendo.
Whatever.
Emile Heskey proves strikers need not necessarily be judged by weight of goals, but when the creative side of a forward’s game is also minimal the debate is more agitated.
It took Berbatov 44 minutes to fashion his only other shot. Yet one perceptive pass by Darren Fletcher, a familiar glimpse of the genius of Ryan Giggs, and he was a match winner. To his credit, he made a point of directing the crowd’s acclaim towards Giggs, who deserves an eternal flame in his honour at Old Trafford.
The Sunday Times' report concentrates on Giggs. All the talk of Giggs (deserved the last couple of games) demonstrates 2 things- first, that Giggs is one of the few Man United players it's OK for people (non-Man Utd fans) to like; and, secondly, that journalists find it very hard to let go of an agenda, in this case, the evergreen-Giggs-match-winner thing. Yes, he made the difference coming on, but all the reports' focusing on Giggs ignore the brilliant pass Fletcher gave him which allowed him to turn the ball onto Berba - it was not so much Gigg's creation, as the team's creation - but it's obviously more palatable for journalists to focus on the lovable Giggs than give our team any credit.
An exception being
The Mail on Sunday's Ian Ridley, who, despite the standard Giggs fare, gives credit to Fletcher:
On the United flanks, Antonio Valencia and Nani were floundering, Berbatov and Wayne Rooney ill-served as a result, and this despite the constant prompting of Paul Scholes who might have been shown a second yellow card on another day after a hand-ball following a foul.
The name of Cristiano Ronaldo was being whispered again. Where would the fire come from? The spark came from Darren Fletcher, who supplied Giggs for the flame of the first goal.
How ironic that Arsene Wenger accused United recently of playing 'anti-football' against his Arsenal side when United were confronted by it yesterday. How ironic that Fletcher, the man allegedly the epitome of the champions' supposed dour approach, should start the move that ensured the spoilers did not prevail.
Telegraph's report is standard fare.
The man at the till is Ryan Giggs, current PFA Player of the Year and the most influential member of this Manchester United side.
There is no need for a receipt, not with goods as good as Giggs.
He was called on at the Britannia Stadium to see United safely through to the checkout, ignoring his aching limbs for this classic cameo.
For 35 minutes, he wandered the aisles that masqueraded as Stoke's defence, stirring the emotions and raiding the shelves.
He was staging his own version of Supermarket Sweep, given a free run of the pitch and filling his boots.
Giggs was excellent, burning brightly on the left of United's midfield after Nani was kicked out of the side entrance.
Ummmm, quite... And I'll try and remember this bit next time we get beat and everyone starts whining about Ronaldo again:
The transition period post-Ronaldo is over, with others emerging from the shadows of the World Player of the Year.
Wayne Rooney was awesome again, so too were the balls that zipped off the feet of Paul Scholes' slippers in the centre of midfield.
Onto the quotes, Sir Alex:
"Ryan is important," said Ferguson. "He made the goals.
"I felt his intelligence would give them a bit of bother on that side of the pitch. Nani did pretty well but Ryan gives you something else.
"He has the intelligence to take up good positions. For the first goal he went on a lovely run behind their defence and the second was an excellent free-kick."
“Chelsea have lost so this was a good three points for us. I just wish I was saying this in May!
But it has been a good day for us.”
Other business; Henry Winter calls for Gary Neville to be employed by the FA:
Inviting such a poacher as Neville to turn gamekeeper would be an inspired move by the FA. It would keep the Government quiet, following Whitehall’s desire for a breath of fresh air to blow through what it believes to be the land of the old farts. Hurricane Neville would certainly do that. It would also call Neville’s bluff.
Having been such an arch-critic of the FA, questioning its decisions and claiming it was out of touch, Neville risks ridicule if he turned down the chance to reshape such an important organisation.
Neville is disliked by those outside Old Trafford for his one-eyed allegiance to United and his prickly demeanour. Yet remove the red shirt and red-tinted glasses and wait for the chippiness to subside. Really listen to the substance of his words not the tetchy delivery.
A lifetime member of the Grouchy Club, Neville actually talks a lot of sense. He can be the sport’s conscience, reminding everyone of the need for a powerful work ethic, of winning, of making the most of your talent (as he has himself done so doggedly).
Sir Alex has money on Ronaldo finishing as top scorer in Spain.
Nice article praising Sir Alex by
Ian Ridley in The Mail on Sunday:
...he could not, however, conceal the softer, sporting side of his nature at Sir Bobby Robson's suitably memorable memorial service.Speaking without notes but with a full heart, Ferguson offered a quotation that deserves repeating and remembering. 'We have a saying at our club,' he said. 'In victory, we deserve it. In defeat, we need it.'
Now, I can almost see the spluttering of a coffee-and-cereal mix across the brunch table as I write these words.
Sir Alex Ferguson talking about the need for defeat and by implication the acceptance of it gracefully? Surely United never lose, the other team simply score more goals by some fluky means?
Though a winner, with a variety of clubs in a range of countries, Sir Bobby knew how to lose, as Ferguson pointed out when citing his fellow knight's grace after Aberdeen had beaten Ipswich in a European tie.
Sir Bobby once rightly urged a tetchy Arsenal to return to their core values after his Newcastle side had beaten them at Highbury.
We all know how hard defeat for our team can be to bear, especially in the heat of the moment. Retaining one's sangfroid, though, while resentment courses through the veins, is what sets apart individuals of class, however.
Sir Alex's motto enables him and his club to enjoy their triumphs with satisfaction, as we all should. It also tells why defeat can be even more valuable to console those of us who experience it more often than does Ferguson.
Amid the game's noise, we need reminders of its nobility.
Sir Alex praises Fletcher:
“Darren has matured so much over the last year or so and I think it’s fair to say that not so long ago he wasn’t considered as a regular player.
“That isn’t the case now. At the moment, it is impossible for me not to pick him for any of our big games.
“That’s how influential he has become. His form in the last year has been absolutely magnificent and he seems to perform even better in the big-game situations.
“John O’Shea is the same. The two of them have matured to the level where they are now key players for our club.
“These two players will be the ones that will take over the spirit of the club from players who have been here a long time like Ryan Giggs, Paul Scholes and Gary Neville.
“Manchester United always needs players who are local or home-grown. Fletcher is one of those now and he will be someone who others look up to.”
And
The Telegraph have extensive words from Fletcher himself, worth reading the whole thing, here on Roy Keane:
"On the pitch and in the dressing room, Roy was always fantastic for me. He was constantly reiterating what it means to play for United, what it takes professionally. "He always used to tell me, 'I get on your back because I want you to do well. If I ignore you, that's when you should be worried'. It is something that has always stuck with me.
"He was constantly there and I learned so much from him. The player I am now, and the way I am off the pitch, my professional levels, has all come from that.
"The biggest thing was the infamous MUTV video, which was really a kick up the backside for everyone. Anything Roy ever said, it was always done to fire you up. He was never going to tiptoe around people or put an arm around your shoulder.
"He used to make comments around the training ground and maybe get a bit annoyed at me because I snapped around at his ankles, but if he did have a go at me, I thought 'right, I'm going to prove you wrong'. That's the reaction he wanted."
Two days after Keane's interview, Fletcher reached his nadir when he was booed off the pitch as United slumped to defeat against Lille in Paris.
"It wasn't easy, but it was character-building stuff," he admits. "I could have gone away and hid and played within myself, but that's not me.
"Don't get me wrong because, at times, it wasn't easy going on to the pitch and being singled out, but you have to learn from it."
Wayne Rooney is already planning for life in coaching – at the tender age of 23.
The Manchester United striker is joining senior Old Trafford team-mates Rio Ferdinand, Paul Scholes and Edwin van der Sar on a course to become a UEFA-qualified coach.
Sunday Mirror Sport can reveal that the United quartet have the blessing of manager Sir Alex Ferguson.
Ferguson was so struck by the England striker’s love of the game that he felt coaching was a good place to channel his energy.
Ferguson said: “The thing that strikes you about Rooney is that he is absolutely football mad.
“He loves training so much that you have to drag him off the pitch. He even plays in goal.
“Sometimes I think I’m going to have to sit on him to stop him playing too much.”
Van der Sar still has the hunger:
“I don’t want to pack it in. At the end of my holiday this summer, I was itching to go back to the training ground.“I have the hunger to win the Champions League again. It does not matter that I won it in the past.
“The season could not start soon enough for me and it was unfortunate I got injured. After our pre-season tour in Korea, I said something about my future and the next day it was all over the back pages that I wanted to ruin Foster’s World Cup dream.
“That was nonsense. Foster got more playing time than ever last season because I was taking rests.
“I think Foster has done well as my replacement. But I still work as hard as all the others at training, whether I’m old enough to be their dad or not.”
Looking forward to the Champions League,
Sir Alex on Wolfsburg:
“They are a massive team physically.
“That’s going to be an issue, so the writing’s on the wall.
“Their striker, Edin Dzeko, got a lot of goals last season and attracted interest from a lot of clubs.
“He’s useful and a handful. And their home record is fantastic. “But it was a surprise when they won the Bundesliga.
“In the Champions League, you expect to be facing Bayern Munich in particular, or Werder Bremen or Schalke from Germany.
“So this is an interesting tie and a new challenge for us.
“As ever, we will aim for ten points to qualify from the group and I want them before our last match, because that is away to Wolfsburg and that will be a difficult game.
“It’s a tricky group we are in with Besiktas and CSKA Moscow in addition to Wolfsburg, but one we should be able to navigate our way through.”
Finally, Tevez is insane I reckon. He spends all summer (and before) slagging and then can't believe that we've gone off him, yeah he worked for us, but his words, and subsequent actions, spoke louder. Anyway,
he gets one of his Man City team mates to speak his words today, continues slagging us off:
“Carlos has always been a player who gives his team 100 per cent. “He helped West Ham to stay in the Premier League and the fans still love him there and he respects them.
“He gave United everything as well. He won the Premier League for them and the Champions’ League.
“He helped them be successful. To be treated as he was at Old Trafford made him understand he made the right choice when he came to City.
Yeah, he singlehandedly won us the Premiership and Champions League. Insane I tell you...